High-temperature superconductor cooled with liquid nitrogen. The prediction if and when a material becomes superconducting depends decisively on whether excitations require energy or not. However, a prediction of that property is more difficult than imagined, as an underlying mathematical problem has proven to be unsolvable in principle. - Photo: Ulli Benz / TUM
High-temperature superconductor cooled with liquid nitrogen. The prediction if and when a material becomes superconducting depends decisively on whether excitations require energy or not. However, a prediction of that property is more difficult than imagined, as an underlying mathematical problem has proven to be unsolvable in principle. - Photo: Ulli Benz / TUM

Gödel and Turing enter quantum physicsQuantum physics problem proved unsolvable

A mathematical problem underlying fundamental questions in particle and quantum physics is provably unsolvable, according to scientists at UCL, Universidad Complutense de Madrid – ICMAT and Technical University of Munich. It is the first major problem in physics for which such a fundamental limitation could be proven. The findings are important because they show that even a perfect and complete description of the microscopic properties of a material is not enough to predict its macroscopic behavior.

A small spectral gap – the energy needed to transfer an electron from a low-energy state to an excited state – is the central property of semiconductors. In a similar way, the spectral gap plays an important role for many other materials. When this energy becomes very small – i.e. the spectral gap closes – it becomes possible for the material to transition to a completely different state. An example of this is when a material becomes superconducting.

Mathematically extrapolating from a microscopic description of a material to the bulk solid is considered one of the key tools in the search for materials exhibiting superconductivity at ambient temperatures or other desirable properties. A study, published today in Nature, however, shows crucial limits to this approach. Using sophisticated mathematics, the authors proved that, even with a complete microscopic description of a quantum material, determining whether it has a spectral gap is, in fact, an undecidable question.

“Alan Turing is famous for his role in cracking the Enigma code,” says Co-author, Dr. Toby Cubitt from UCL Computer Science. “But amongst mathematicians and computer scientists, he is even more famous for proving that certain mathematical questions are ‘undecidable' – they are neither true nor false, but are beyond the reach of mathematics. What we’ve shown is that the spectral gap is one of these undecidable problems. This means a general method to determine whether matter described by quantum mechanics has a spectral gap, or not, cannot exist. Which limits the extent to which we can predict the behavior of quantum materials, and potentially even fundamental particle physics.”

One million dollars to win!

The most famous problem concerning spectral gaps is whether the theory governing the fundamental particles of matter itself – the standard model of particle physics – has a spectral gap (the `Yang-Mills mass gap' conjecture). Particle physics experiments such as CERN and numerical calculations on supercomputers suggest that there is a spectral gap. Although there is a $1m prize at stake from the Clay Mathematics Institute for whoever can, no one has yet succeeded in proving this mathematically from the equations of the standard model.

Dr. Cubitt added, “It's possible for particular cases of a problem to be solvable even when the general problem is undecidable, so someone may yet win the coveted $1m prize. But our results do raise the prospect that some of these big open problems in theoretical physics could be provably unsolvable.”

"We knew about the possibility of problems that are undecidable in principle since the works of Turing and Gödel in the 1930s,” added Co-author Professor Michael Wolf from Technical University of Munich. “So far, however, this only concerned the very abstract corners of theoretical computer science and mathematical logic. No one had seriously contemplated this as a possibility right in the heart of theoretical physics before. But our results change this picture. From a more philosophical perspective, they also challenge the reductionists’ point of view, as the insurmountable difficulty lies precisely in the derivation of macroscopic properties from a microscopic description."

Not all bad news

Co-author, Professor David Pérez-García from Universidad Complutense de Madrid and ICMAT, said: “It's not all bad news, though. The reason this problem is impossible to solve in general is because models at this level exhibit extremely bizarre behavior that essentially defeats any attempt to analyze them. But this bizarre behavior also predicts some new and very weird physics that hasn't been seen before. For example, our results show that adding even a single particle to a lump of matter, however large, could in principle dramatically change its properties. New physics like this is often later exploited in technology.”

The researchers are now seeing whether their findings extend beyond the artificial mathematical models produced by their calculations to more realistic quantum materials that could be realized in the laboratory.

The research has been funded by the John Templeton Foundation, the Royal Society (UK), the Spanish Ministry of Economics and Competitiveness (MINECO), the Madrid Regional Government and the European Research Council (ERC).


Undecidability of the Spectral Gap, Toby S. Cubitt, David Perez-Garcia, Michael M. Wolf; Nature, Dec. 10, 2015 – under embargo: 19.00 MEZ / 13.00 US Eastern Time on 9 December 2015.
DOI: 10.1038/nature16059


Prof. Dr. Michael M. Wolf
Technical University of Munich
Boltzmannstr. 3, 85748 Garching, Germany
Tel.: +49 89 289 17002E-MailWeb

Technical University of Munich

Corporate Communications Center Dr. Andreas Battenberg

Article at tum.de

First proof of quantum computer advantage

Quantum computers promise to revolutionize the future of computing. A scientist from the Technical University of Munich (TUM) together with his colleagues from the University of Waterloo and from IBM have now demonstrated...

Zukunftsvision: Quantencomputer mit Chips aus Diamant und Graphen – Grafik: Christoph Hohmann / NIM

Center for Quantum Engineering comes to Garching

In recent years, a globally esteemed research focus on quantum technologies has developed on the Garching campus. The German Council of Science and Humanities now supports the creation of a new central institute at the...

Eine neue Methode erlaubt, die Verschränkung von quantenmechnischen Vielteilchensystemen zu messen.

Sensitive quantum particles

The quantum mechanical entanglement of particles plays an important role in many technical applications. To date, however, the effect has been difficult to measure experimentally. Physicists from the Technical University of...

Andrew Crampton und Marian Rötzer an ihrer Vakuum-Anlage zur Herstellung ultrakleiner Katalysatorpartikel - Foto: Andreas Heddergott / TUM

Small is different

In the production of margarine millions of tons of unsaturated fatty acids are converted from vegetable oils using hydrogen. While searching for improved catalysts for these so-called hydrogenation reactions, a...

Elektron im Quanten-Punkt, beeinflusst von Kernspins der Umgebung – Grafik: Fabian Flassig / TUM

Quantum computer made of standard semiconductor materials

Physicists at the Technical University of Munich, the Los Alamos National Laboratory and Stanford University (USA) have tracked down semiconductor nanostructure mechanisms that can result in the loss of stored information –...

Eine App liefert intuitive graphische Darstellungen von Quantenzuständen gekoppelter Spins - Bild: Steffen Glaser / TUM

Visualizing the “matrix”

Magnetic resonance tomography (MRT) images are an important diagnostic tool. The achievable contrast depends on how well the nuclear spins that form the basis of the imaging signals can be controlled. Mathematically, the...

Jitae Park am PUMA-Dreiachsen-Spektrometer – Foto: Volker Lannert / DAAD

Refocusing research into high-temperature superconductors

Scientists around the globe are trying to understand the phenomenon of loss-free electric power transmission by high-temperature superconductors. Materials that exhibit this effect at room temperature would bear huge...