Patients that participated in 12 weeks of regular supervised exercise had better effects than those who just got a recommendation to train on their own. (Photo: iStock/ monkeybusinessimages)
Patients that participated in 12 weeks of regular supervised exercise had better effects than those who just got a recommendation to train on their own. (Photo: iStock/ monkeybusinessimages)
  • Research news

3,000 Steps in 30 Minutes Improves the Prognosis for Heart FailureSupervised Exercise Training Helps Patients with Heart Failure

Contrary to what was previously assumed about patients with heart failure, physical exercise does not lead to harmful ventricular enlargement. Researchers at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) and the Norwegian University of Science and Technology in Trondheim (NTNU) have disproved this earlier hypothesis and issued recommendations for designing a training program for persons with congestive heart failure.

Congestive heart failure is among the most frequent causes of death in industrialized countries. As a consequence of this condition, the patient’s heart is no longer capable of adequately supplying the body with blood and oxygen. Until now, the prognosis for congestive heart failure has been poor and comparable to that of cancer.

Previous Recommendations Included Drug Therapy and Defibrillators, No Training

“Previously, congestive heart failure was primarily treated with drugs. The range of treatments was expanded by the use of cardiac pacemakers to optimize heart muscle contraction and the implantation of defibrillators intended to improve myocardial function and prevent sudden cardiac death due to arrhythmia”, explained Professor Martin Halle, Professor of Preventive and Rehabilitative Sports Medicine at TU Munich.

Heart failure patients were in fact strictly forbidden from engaging in physical training because of fears that this would further compromise the heart’s pumping function. However, studies in recent years have already shown that by adding physical training, one can achieve positive effects on endurance and reduce the chances of rehospitalization due to worsening of the symptoms (rehospitalization rate).

For a study conducted in nine European centers and recently published in the American Heart Association journal Circulation investigated the effects of different forms of physical training on a damaged heart. “With this study, we are able to prove that exercise training does not deteriorate dilatation and function of the heart and seems to be safe”, concluded Professor Halle, Medical Director of the TUM Department for Prevention and Sports Medicine.

Between 2009 and 2014, 261 patients with heart failure were assigned to three groups, and over 52 weeks, they underwent different intensities of training. Initially, all three groups underwent supervised training for three months and in addition, they were given the recommendation to continue the intervention for another nine months.

Patients that participated in 12 weeks of regular supervised exercise had better effects than those who just got a recommendation to train on their own. “We actually observed a decrease in the size of the left ventricle, and with it, an improvement in pumping function”, said Professor Halle. “This increased their physical fitness.” The study did not detect any significant differences between a new program of interval training at high intensity and a standard therapy with continuous exercise at moderate intensity. “We actually observed that this training revealed the best improvements and that not exercising was significantly worse regarding pump function and hospitalization”, said Professor Halle.

Moderate Training Is Defined as Around a Hundred Steps per Minute

“Overall, this new study underscores how advisable regular physical training at moderate intensity is for patients with systolic heart failure”, Halle concluded – “but I would rather discourage high intensity exercise until larger studies will prove this to be as safe.” The doctor also offered the following concrete tip: Moderate training means around one hundred steps per minute or 3,000 steps in 30 minutes.

The benefits of individualized exercise therapy for cardiac patients include:

•    decreased strain on the heart
•    improvement of the heart muscles function
•    improvement of blood vessels dilation
•    forming of new blood vessels
•    lowering of elevated blood pressure
•    improved oxygen uptake for energy production
•    improved endurance and performance
•    decreased risk of cardiac and vascular emergencies such as heart attack and stroke


Øyvind Ellingsen, Martin Halle, Viviane M. Conraads, Asbjørn Støylen, Håvard Dalen, Charles Delagardelle, Alf-Inge Larsen, Torstein Hole, Alessandro Mezzani, Emeline M. Van Craenenbroeck, Vibeke Videm, Paul J. Beckers, Jeffrey W. Christle, Ephraim B. Winzer, Norman Mangner, Felix Woitek, Robert Höllriegel, Axel P. Pressler, Tea Monk-Hansen, Martin Snoer, Patrick Feiereisen, Torstein Valborgland, John K. Kjekshus, Rainer Hambrecht, Stephan Gielen, Trine Karlsen, Eva B. Prescott, Axel Linke and the SMARTEX Heart Failure Study Group: High Intensity Interval Training in Heart Failure Patients with Reduced Ejection Fraction, Circulation 01/2017. DOI: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.116.022924


Prof. Dr. Martin Halle
Technical University of Munich
Chair of Preventive and Rehabilitative Sports Medicine
Phone: +49/89/289 24431
E-Mail: halle(at)

Corporate Communications Center

Technical University of Munich

Article at

Höhepunkt der „Forscherwochen" ist eine zweitägige Forschungsexpedition mit Experimenten und Untersuchungen im Freien. (Foto: Valerie Frimmer)

Studying outdoors is better

Being taught science subjects outdoors increases student motivation. A study by the Technical University of Munich (TUM) and the University of Mainz therefore suggests offering more outdoor instruction at the lower...

Entgegen bisheriger Studien belegt das Team der TUM, dass sich bei Erstklässlern die sportmotorische Leistungsfähigkeit in den vergangenen zehn Jahren nicht verschlechtert hat. (Foto: iStock/ FatCamera)

First graders fitter than expected

Childhood obesity is often attributed to a lack of exercise. So what about sports among elementary school students? A team from the Technical University of Munich (TUM) pursued this question and collected the results of...

Die Vorsorge nimmt eine Schlüsselrolle ein bei der Eindämmung von Krebs, dazu gehören auch regelmäßige Untersuchungen beim Arzt. (Foto: iStock/psphotograph)

"The beauty is that everyone can be active in prevention"

According to studies, up to 50 percent of cancer cases would be easily preventable. Yet the number of new cancer cases worldwide has increased by over 30 percent in a 10-year time frame up to 2015. The key factor in cancer...

Aufgrund seiner hohen Stoffwechselaktivität haben sich die Wissenschaftler für diese Studie auf den Herzmuskel konzentriert. (Grafik: 7activestudio/ iStock)

Zinc supply affects cardiac health

In addition to essential metabolic functions, the level of zinc in the body also affects the heart muscle. When oxidative stress occurs, it may be due to a shortage of zinc, which can be determined by examining the heart...

Ein Bild eines menschliches Skelett mit künstlichen Halsschlagadern.

microRNA may reduce stroke risk

The molecule microRNA-210 stabilises deposits in the carotid artery and can prevent them from tearing. Thus, it may prevent dangerous blood clots from forming. This is what scientists headed by Prof. Lars Mägdefessel,...

Aufnahme der Blutgefäße auf einem Herzmuskel.

Vanishing capillaries

Diabetics have a significantly higher risk of suffering a heart attack. A research team at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) has now identified one of the causes: Diabetes is associated with the loss of small blood...

Mit einer „optischen Pinzette“ misst Marco Grison die Wechselwirkungen zwischen zwei Proteinen – Bild: Uli Benz / TUM

What holds the heart together

Our hearts beat a life long. With every beat our heart muscle contracts and expands. How this can work throughout an entire life remains largely a mystery. Researchers at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) have now...

Laura Ludwig und Kira Walkenhorst mit ihren olymischen Goldmedallien. (Foto: FIVB)

Analysis program contributes to Olympic victory

Laura Ludwig and Kira Walkenhorst became the first European women’s team to win the gold medal for beach volleyball at the Olympic Games in Rio. The Technical University of Munich (TUM) also had a part in the commanding 2:0...

Zwei Goalball-Spieler versuchen einen gegnerischen Angriff abzuwehren (Foto: Ch. Weber / TUM)

Intelligent analysis is the key to success

The World Goalball Championship will kick off on June 26, 2014, in the Finnish city of Espoo. Goalball is the world’s most popular ball sport among the visually impaired. Germany will be sending both a men’s and a women’s...