TUM – Technical University of Munich Menu
The pumpkin spider is one of the species observed for the study. Their name points to the yellowish-green backbones, which reminds of a pumpkin. (Foto: Charlesjsharp Sharp Photography /Creative-Commons-Lizenz CC BY-SA 3.0)
The pumpkin spider is one of the species observed for the study. Their name points to the yellowish-green backbones, which reminds of a pumpkin. (Foto: Charlesjsharp Sharp Photography /Creative-Commons-Lizenz CC BY-SA 3.0)
  • Research news

Conflict between yield maximization and species conservation in agriculture appears reconcilableHow grassland management without the loss of species works

The intensive management of grasslands is bad for biodiversity. However, a study by the Terrestrial Ecology Research Group at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) has brought a ray of hope: If different forms of management are optimally distributed within a region, this can lead to higher yields without the loss of insect species. In ideal cases, this will allow even more species to find habitats that are optimal for them. What is crucial here is that management is planned at the landscape level.

For this study, data for more than a thousand species of arthropods were evaluated. This data was collected from over a hundred grassland sites (meadows and pastures). The dataset comes from the years 2008 to 2012 and were sampled in the study regions of the Biodiversity Exploratories: Swabian Jura, Hainich-Dün, and Schorfheide-Chorin. Along gradients typical for grassland management in the region — from intensive agriculture to medium-level and extensive management — it was observed how the populations of frequently encountered insects and spiders change.

"In the case of intensive management of grasslands, for example, mowing is carried out three times a year and the grassland is fertilized", explains Dr. Nadja Simons, lead author of the study – "while another grassland is, for example, only used for grazing sheep once a year and is not fertilized. This is the minimal form, so-called extensive management." In Central Europe, grassland that is protected by nature conservation laws is also subjected to management, as they would otherwise gradually turn into forests. Simultaneously, the management of unprotected areas is taking place with increasing intensity. This is fatal for species which can only cope with extensive or medium-level use. Frequently discussed approaches include the maximization of use on a percentage of the areas in order to be able to place additional areas under protection, or alternatively to manage all areas with medium intensity.

Conflict between production increase and species conservation is reconcilable

In contrast to these extremes, the theoretical scenarios of the study which were published in the nature journal "Ecology & Evolution" demonstrated that the conflict between high yields and species conservation could be  better resolved by managing the grassland areas of a region with varying levels of intensity. The recommendation by Dr. Nadja Simons and Professor Wolfgang Weisser for farmers is to exhaust every variant of the wide range of possibilities — and to do this across a wide overall area.

"It is only by doing so that both insect species which require more extreme habitats as well as less demanding all-rounders can find their own special habitat. This is because species could then ideally simply migrate to where they can find the right habitat", says Simons. "If the intensity of use in a region is distributed optimally, the number of species which would benefit is even higher than in the current situation. Theoretically, yields — viewed across an entire region — could then be increased without the population of insects shrinking."

Real-word application possible via collaboration with farmers

But how can the findings of the study be implemented? "This can work in the real world if farmers in a region work together much like in an orchestra, instead of acting on their own like soloists", explains Simons. "On the other hand, if state policies were to consider the management of an entire region instead of only promoting measures on individual areas, this could also lead to the preservation of more species." To date, subsidy measures have only considered individual agricultural operations. However, it would be better if goals were to be set at the landscape level.

For the scientist Dr. Simons, it would be conceivable that the existing computer script which was used to create the model scenarios for her study be further refined. It could then be used to plan the management of grasslands at the landscape level, with the goal of securing habitats for as many groups of species as possible.

But before master plans for the three regions investigated in the Swabian Jura, Hainich-Dün, and Schorfheide-Chorin can be created, the models must first become more complex. There are other limiting factors which need to be taken into account, which will subsequently be discussed with the farmers of the regions investigated.


Nadja K. Simons und Wolfgang W. Weisser: Agricultural intensification without biodiversity loss is possible in grassland landscapes, Nature Ecology and Evolution 6/2017, DOI: 10.1038/s41559-017-0227-2.


Dr. Nadja Simons
Technical University of Munich
Terrestrial Ecology Research Group
Phone: +49.8161.71.3713
Mail: nadja.simons@tum.de

Prof. Dr. Wolfgang W. Weisser
Technical University of Munich
Terrestrial Ecology Research Group
Department of Ecology and Ecosystemmanagement
Phone: +49/8161-71-3496/ -3495
Mail: wolfgang.weisser@tum.de

Corporate Communications Center

Technical University of Munich

Article at tum.de

Populations of insect species, such as the Small Gold Grasshopper (Chrysochraon dispar), have significantly declined.

Insect decline more extensive than suspected

Compared to a decade ago, today the number of insect species on many areas has decreased by about one third. This is the result of a survey of an international research team led by scientists from the Technical University...

Hauhechel-Bläuling (Polyommatus icarus). (Bild: Jan Christian Habel / TUM)

Butterfly numbers down by two thirds

Meadows adjacent to high-intensity agricultural areas are home to less than half the number of butterfly species than areas in nature preserves. The number of individuals is even down to one-third of that number. These are...

Haben Blattläuse die Wahl zwischen Weizenkeimlingen mit (rechts) und ohne CBT-ol-Behandlung (links), so meiden sie die behandelten Keimlinge. (Bilder: W. Mischko / TUM)

Organic insect deterrent for agriculture

Traditional insecticides are killers: they not only kill pests, they also endanger bees and other beneficial insects, as well as affecting biodiversity in soils, lakes, rivers and seas. A team from the Technical University...

Der vom Forscherteam untersuchte Kleine Holzbohrer in einem Gang mit weißlich zu sehendem Pilzbewuchs. (Foto: G. Kunz für P. Biedermann/JMU)

Why some beetles fly on alcohol

The Ambrosia beetle looks specifically for drunken trees to nest. Now researchers have found out why he is doing this: it is due to his sophisticated agricultural system. The beetle optimises its harvest with alcohol as a...

Hauhechelbläuling Polyommatus icarus, einer der häufigsten Bläulinge mit stark abnehmenden Populationen. (Foto: J. Habel/ TUM)

Insect die-off: Even common species are becoming rare

Together with their colleagues from the Senckenberg German Entomological Institute, scientists of Technical University of Munich (TUM) were able to show that currently widespread insects are threatened with a serious...

Das Jena Experiment beweist aufgrund seiner Breite erstmals, dass ein Verlust der Artenvielfalt negative Konsequenzen für viele einzelne Komponenten und Prozesse in Ökosystemen hat. (Foto: Das Jena Experiment)

Loss of species destroys ecosystems

How serious is the loss of species globally? Are material cycles in an ecosystem with few species changed? In order to find this out, the "Jena Experiment" was established in 2002, one of the largest biodiversity...

Eine blühende Wiese bietet neben dem ästhetischen Wert auch noch täglich handfeste, kostenlose Dienstleistungen für den Menschen. (Foto: Fotolia/ J. Fälchle)

Flowering meadows benefit humankind

The more it swarms, crawls and flies the better it is for humans. This is the finding of a study published in “Nature”. More than 60 researchers from a number of universities were involved, including the Technical...

Die Acker-Witwenblume (Knautia arvensis) zeigt ausgeprägte genetische Unterschiede zwischen Nord- und Süddeutschland und zusätzlich noch regionale Anpassung. (Foto: Walter Durka)

Regional seed material performs better

Colorful and extensively used meadows and pastures provide valuable habitats for many plant and animal species. However, they have become very rare. In order to re-establish such grasslands, the plants they contain must be...

„Die Beobachtung über einen Zeitraum von 200 Jahren bestätigt den allgemeinen Trend, dass spezialisierte Schmetterlingsarten stark rückläufig sind, obwohl sie im Fokus des Naturschutzes stehen“, sagt Dr. Jan Christian Habel. (Foto: TUM/ J. Habel)

Nature conservation areas no haven for butterflies

What do the brimstone, meadow brown and small heath butterfly species have in common? All of them are rather habitat specialists, with no specific ecological demands, they tend to have modest requirements when it comes to...

Die Häufigkeit von Arten unterliegt Schwankungen. Dies sind die gepunkteten Linien. Die durchschnittliche Schwankung der Gemeinschaft, die schwarze Linie, schwankt stärker, wenn sich die Arten synchron zueinander entwickeln (Grafik unten). Schwanken sie hingegen asynchron wie in der Grafik links, ist die Artengemeinschaft insgesamt sehr stabil und die schwarze Linie ist ausgeglichen. (Abb.: TUM/ Gossner)

Asynchrony of species is more important than diversity

Whether an animal or plant community remains stable despite external impacts does not depend on biological diversity alone: asynchrony across the species is also a crucial factor. The more the species in an ecosystem...