TUM – Technical University of Munich Menu
A man hands documents to a robot.
Robots are expected to take over a lot of work in the near future.
Image: istockphoto.com / YakobchukOlena
  • Research news
  • Reading time: 3 MIN

Study assesses psychological impact of job losses through technology

Employees less upset at being replaced by robots than by other people

Generally speaking, most people find the idea of workers being replaced by robots or software worse than if the jobs are taken over by other workers. But when their own jobs are at stake, people would rather prefer to be replaced by robots than by another employee. That is the conclusion of a study by the Technical University of Munich (TUM) and Erasmus University in Rotterdam.

Over the coming decades, millions of jobs will be threatened by robotics and artificial intelligence. Despite intensive academic debate on these developments, there has been little study on how workers react to being replaced through technology.

To find out, business researchers at TUM and Erasmus University Rotterdam conducted 11 scenarios studies and surveys with over 2,000 persons from several countries in Europe and North America. Their findings have now been published in the renowned journal Nature Human Behaviour.

Human replacements pose greater threat to feeling of self-worth

The study shows: In principle, most people view it more favorably when workers are replaced by other people than by robots or intelligent software. This preference reverses, however, when it refers to people's own jobs. When that is the case, the majority of workers find it less upsetting to see their own jobs go to robots than to other employees. In the long term, however, the same people see machines as more threatening to their future role in the workforce. These effects can also be observed among people who have recently become unemployed.  
 
The researchers were able to identify the causes behind these seemingly paradoxical results, too: People tend to compare themselves less with machines than with other people. Consequently, being replaced by a robot or a software poses less of a threat to their feeling of self-worth. This reduced self-threat could even be observed when participants assumed that they were being replaced by other employees who relied on technological abilities such as artificial intelligence in their work.

Weaker organized resistance?

"Even when unemployment results from the introduction of new technologies, people still judge it in a social context," says Christoph Fuchs, a professor of the TUM School of Management, one of the authors of the study. "It is important to understand these psychological effects when trying to manage the massive changes in the working world to minimize disruptions in society."

For example, the insights could help to design better programs for the unemployed. "For people who have lost their job to a robot, boosting their self-esteem will be less of a priority," says Fuchs. "In that case it is more important to teach them new skills that will reduce their concerns about losing out to robots in the long term."

The study could also serve as a starting point for further research on other economic topics, says Fuchs: “It is conceivable that employee representatives' responses to job losses attributed to automation will tend to be weaker than when other causes are involved, for example outsourcing.”

Publications:

Granulo, Armin, Fuchs, Christoph, Puntoni, Stefano: Psychological reactions to human versus robotic job replacement, Nature Human Behaviour 2019. DOI: 10.1038/s41562-019-0670-y

Corporate Communications Center

Technical University of Munich Klaus Becker
klaus.becker(at)tum.de

Contacts to this article:

Prof. Christoph Fuchs, Ph.D.
Technical University of Munich (TUM)
Chair of Marketing
Tel: +49 89 289 28401
christoph.fuchs(at)tum.de

Article at tum.de

Christina Miller with the modular robot-arm.

A toolbox for building robots aware of their surroundings

Many work processes would be almost unthinkable today without robots. But robots operating in manufacturing facilities have often posed risks to workers because they are not responsive enough to their surroundings. To make...

Man speaks in front of an audience with a headset

DAX executives earning less

Earnings of management board members of companies listed on the DAX exchange were 3.5 percent lower on average in 2018 than in the previous year. The companies have also linked executive compensation more closely to stock...

Mann mit Virtual-Reality-Brille entwirft eine Turbine

Radical changes through virtual reality

Virtual and augmented reality will have potential applications in countless business sectors as the technologies mature. A study by economists at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) shows that drastic disruption lies...

Männer in Anzügen auf Rolltreppen in entgegengesetzten Richtungen

CEOs change course when they resemble their predecessors

The greater the similarity of newly appointed CEOs to their predecessors, the more likely they are to change the company's strategy. This result – contrary to prevailing opinion in the field – was demonstrated in a study by...

Prof. Gordon Cheng.

"Robots help us to understand humans"

At the opening ceremony of the 2014 Soccer World Cup in Brazil a paraplegic Brazilian man kicked off the first ball of the tournament himself. The young man was wearing an exoskeleton whose movements he controlled using his...