Green warming stripes for first spring (forsythia flowering) in Bavaria, Germany (1951-2020)
This example of the new display format shows the forsythia bloom in Bavaria from 1951 to 2020. In recent years, it can be observed earlier and earlier.
Image: Ye Yuan & Annette Menzel / TUM
  • Sustainability, Research news
  • Reading time: 2 MIN

Interview with Professor Annette Menzel on the idea of Green Warming StripesEffects of climate change on nature visualized

To illustrate the effects of climate change on nature at a glance, scientists at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) are now presenting Green Warming Stripes for the first time. Annette Menzel, Professor of Ecoclimatology at the TUM, explains in an interview how we can interpret them and what they mean.

We understand that Green Climate or Warming Stripes can illustrate nature’s responses to global warming, but how can we decode the colored stripes?

Blue colors represent years with cold weather and their consequent later flower or leaf development. Green Stripes represent warm years with earlier plant development. We have created the Green Warming Stripes for Bavaria and some historical observation series in other areas of Central Europe.

Many people probably know similar images - only in different colors- from the coverage of the “Fridays for Future” demonstrations...

The Green Climate Stripes or “Green Warming Stripes” are a further development of the well-known “Warming Stripes” by Ed Hawkins, which simply visualize the warming over the last decades in blue and red color and communicate it without frills.

What exactly are the new “Green Warming Stripes” about?

Phenological events such as leaf unfolding, flowering, and fruit ripening are a perfect bioindicator of climate change. They advance by up to 5 days for every 1 degree Celsius of warming. Take the hazel blossom in Bavaria, for example. In recent years, hazel blossoming has been observed more than 20 days earlier than in the period between 1971 and 2000. The Green Warming Stripes thus perfectly compliment the purely temperature-based Warming Stripes because they impressively show the directly observable effects of climate change on nature. For example, earlier flowering of allergenic plants means a longer period of suffering for pollen allergy sufferers, and budding of trees in April instead of May is associated with a higher risk of late frosts.

The images currently available cover a fairly wide range of phenological changes. Do you plan to create more stripes for other regions or phenophases?

Green Warming Stripes are currently available for several phenological seasons in Bavaria and some other historical 120-year time series such as the cherry blossom at Geisenheim in the German Rheingau. In plant phenology, the year is not divided into four seasons but into ten “phenological seasons”: Early, First, and Full Spring; Early, Mid and Late Summer; Early, Full, and Late Autumn; and Winter. This classification is based on the phenomena in the plant world with regard to flowering as well as fruit ripening, leaf coloration, and leaf shedding. For example, hazel blossoming indicates the phenological season early spring, while horse chestnut fruit ripening marks full autumn. We plan to expand the range of Green Warming Stripes step by step to include additional historical time series and other regions.

More information:

The Green Warming Stripes are available and can be downloaded from the project website of the Bavarian Synthesis Information Citizen Science Portal for Climate Research and Science Communication.

In the latest issue of Faszination Forschung, the interdisciplinary research network BAYSICS is presented. It aims to involve citizens in research on climate change. Annette Menzel initiated and coordinates the project. Click here to go directly to the article "Climate Change in your Backyard".

BAYSICS is a collaborative project in the Bavarian Network for Climate Research that aims to make climate change tangible for citizens in their own environment. Using a web application or app, participants can record observations of plants, allergenic species, tree borders, and animals and thus contribute to the observational treasure trove. Their own observations can be correlated with existing data sets and observations from other users thereby demonstrating where and how climate change is affecting our everyday lives.

High-resolution images

Technical University of Munich

Corporate Communications Center Dr. Katharina Baumeister-Krojer

Contacts to this article:

Prof. Dr. Annette Menzel
Professorship of Ecoclimatology
Technical University of Munich
Tel.: +49 8161 714 740

Article at

Prof. Sara Leonhardt

Forests and bees - a coexistence for biodiversity?

With the topics of bees and bee mortality as well as forests and their structures, the next lectures in the series "TUM@Freising - Science Explained for All" will take place online for the first time on Tuesday, April 27,...

Watzmann massif

Exploring biodiversity and climate change in the Alps

Technical University of Munich (TUM) and Berchtesgaden National Park have commenced a project for the permanent monitoring of biodiversity. At 50 locations in the National Park, the research team is going to gather...