Discovering a forgotten biosignal
Breathing rate predicts therapeutic benefits for heart patients
Sudden cardiac death is one of the leading causes of mortality in western industrialized countries. It can be prevented by an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD). This automatically detects life-threatening heart rhythms and emits electrical signals to stop them. The guidelines recommend the implantation of ICDs in patients with a significantly weakened pump function of the left ventricle. According to the German Heart Surgery Report, more than 42,000 defibrillators were implanted in Germany in 2018.
However, the effectiveness of implanting ICDs is sometimes questionable. The latest Heart Surgery Report by the German Heart Foundation also notes that the benefits of defibrillator therapy are not as clear-cut as previously believed. Moreover, they are often offset by relatively common complications arising both during and after the implantation procedure.
Researchers at TUM have now demonstrated that the nocturnal respiratory rate of heart patients – which has hitherto received little attention – can help to predict the success of ICD treatment. Between May 2014 and September 2018 they monitored 1,971 heart patients at 44 European heart centers. 1,363 of the patients received an ICD, while the control group was treated conservatively. The different treatment options were dictated by the varying availability of ICD therapy at the participating European centers. Consequently, the study was non-randomized. However, the resulting distortions were compensated for through sophisticated statistical analysis. The study has now been published in eClinicalMedicine, an open-access journal produced by the renowned journal The Lancet.
In both groups the scientists measured the average nocturnal respiratory rate between midnight and 6 am based on an ECG protocol. The ICD patients had a survival advantage of 31.3 percent over the control group. At the same time, a significant link was seen between a low nocturnal respiratory rate and reduced mortality: ICD patients with a rate below 18 breaths per minute had a 50 percent survival advantage as compared to the control group, while those with a higher nocturnal respiratory rate gained no survival advantage through the defibrillator.
“The breathing rate has been largely ignored as a biosignal in the field of cardiology,” says Prof. Georg Schmidt, the last author of the study, who heads the working group for biosignal processing at TUM’s university hospital Klinikum rechts der Isar. “Our conclusions will now place a greater focus on this parameter,” says Prof. Schmidt, noting that the study demonstrates the predictive value of breathing frequency for therapeutic efficacy. “Especially in borderline cases, checking the patient’s breathing rate can help to decide on the right therapy.”
Against this backdrop, Schmidt, who also chairs the TUM Ethics Commission, believes that it would be reasonable to aim for a randomized study versus the established guidelines. “This would involve dividing the patients observed to gain no advantage from the ICD in our study into two groups, with one having an ICD implanted and the other receiving conservative treatment. If a randomized study of this kind reveals that heart patients with a higher nocturnal breathing rate do not benefit from the ICD implant, they could be spared this invasive treatment in the future.”
M. Dommasch, A. Steger, G. Schmidt et. al.: Nocturnal respiratory rate predicts ICD benefit: a prospective, controlled, multicentre cohort study. EClinicalMedicine (2020). DOI: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2020.100695
The first authors of the study, funded by the European Union, are Michael Dommasch and Alexander Steger of TUM. The study was carried out at 44 centers in 15 countries. Prof. Markus Zabel of Herzzentrum Göttingen organized the Europe-wide set-up. The Department of Medical Statistics at the University of Göttingen, headed by Prof. Tim Friede, provided support with the statistical data management.
Contacts to this article:
Prof. Dr. Georg Schmidt
Technical University of Munich
Klinikum rechts der Isar
Clinic and Polyclinic for Internal Medicine I, Cardiology
Tel: + 089 289 22731